I long for the days where English traditions like penny for the guy dominated, and carol singers, what happened to kids that did these? I mean, I know they grew up, but why did the tradition stop
Halloween has always been a thing here it's just enjoying a resurgence right now.
The thing with Penny for the Guy is that back then you could do more with a penny. These days for there to be any point you'd have to ask for a fair bit more and that's where you come unstuck, knocking on a door that looks like it's happy to participate, ie, it has Halloween decorations up in the hope of a sweet is one thing. Knocking on random doors asking for money is quite another.
I'm happy to hand over a few pence worth of sweets but i'm not giving money out, I just don't have it for a start.
As for carol singers I've no idea but possibly the same reason, few people want them, much more likely to get told to go away for little or no return and these days it's usually wet and horrible around that time of year instead of just dry but cold. If we had some round here I'd possibly give them a chocolate or something my OH is far less charitable lol.