He's trying to make an entirely invalid point.
Because he's like that.
What most people fail to understand is that the idea of a Meritocracy was first put forward as a kind of Dystopia - now it seems to be some kind of default Utopia of the narrow of mind.
Merit is something that will be always measurable to the meritorious. Having merited their meritorious Meritocracy they will naturally be contemptuous of anybody who has 'failed' to merit the same achievements. Their over-arching self belief will naturally cause them to condemn those that cut not the mustard as feckless blowhards that pull not their weight.
One can only assume that concepts such as empathy are little more than indulgent weakness in this self-regarding orgy of 'merit'. What you have to understand is that the very fact that you don't
own your house means that you are on a lower rung. The fact that you might expect to have such a lowly rung actually
improved - well, that quite takes the biscuit.
Mr.shoes can't expect someone to come round and improve his kitchen, oh no, because he is a proud property owner so must make do and mend like some sort of Blitz survivor. Who will come and repair
his roof when it is bombed?
That's right, no one. Because he has to soldier on with no back-up. But that's all right, because he is a resourceful chap who is locked and loaded with one in the spout. Because he has earned it. Because he is worth it.
But you are not. You are not worthy of the respect of one such as he. Because you have presumably squandered your life-chances - the exact same chances that he had that he took full advantage of. Had you not squandered those exact same chances, you too would live in the quasi-paradise of supra-suburban bliss with your cheap date and your rescued dogs.
But you don't. And if we have learned nothing else, we have learned that it is most definitely your fault.
Now, somebody else might think to themselves, hold on a minute - if shoes buys a new kitchen it will add value to his property, if you buy a new kitchen it will add value to the person you bought the kitchen off and not you. But because you are without merit we can of course chuck such thoughts out of the undeveloped kitchen window. Only the meritorious merit such extended thought processes.
I hope i have been in some way helpful in explaining why you don't deserve a new kitchen.